James Marriott on Reading – Econlib
Reading on a phone or a Kindle is convenient, but it lacks the tactile experience and immersive feeling of holding a physical book in your hands. James Marriott’s decision to get rid of his smartphone in order to read more books is a bold move that highlights the importance of prioritizing reading in a world filled with distractions.
When we are constantly bombarded with notifications, emails, and social media updates, it’s easy to lose sight of the joy and benefits of reading a good book. Marriott’s commitment to reading one to two books a week, along with his preference for physical books over digital copies, serves as a reminder of the value of carving out time for deep, uninterrupted reading.
The idea of reading 50 pages at a sitting might seem daunting to some, but setting a goal for the amount of pages to read in one sitting can help maintain focus and engagement with the material. By immersing oneself in a book for an extended period of time, the reader can fully appreciate the nuances of the text and stay connected to the story or subject matter.
Marriott’s decision to switch to a “dumb phone” in order to reduce distractions and prioritize reading is a testament to the transformative power of literature. By eliminating the constant temptation of checking social media or browsing the internet, Marriott has created a space for himself to fully engage with books and immerse himself in the world of storytelling.
In a time of uncertainty and chaos, such as the ongoing conflict in Israel, finding solace in the pages of a book can provide a much-needed escape and a source of comfort. Instead of doom-scrolling through news feeds and social media, taking the time to read a book can offer a sense of peace and perspective that is hard to find elsewhere.
Ultimately, Marriott’s dedication to reading serves as a powerful reminder of the importance of making time for literature in our busy lives. Whether it’s setting aside a few minutes each day to read, committing to a specific number of pages per sitting, or eliminating distractions to focus on a good book, prioritizing reading can enrich our lives and expand our minds in ways that are truly invaluable.
But, my rule of thumb is to always look for the classic. Look for the book that has stood the test of time, the one that scholars and readers have been turning to for decades or even centuries. Because, chances are, if a book has been continuously recommended and studied for that long, it’s because it offers something truly valuable and timeless.
For example, when it comes to Voltaire, instead of picking up the latest biography that just hit the shelves, why not go for “Voltaire in His Letters” by the man himself? Or delve into “Candide,” his satirical novella that continues to be relevant and thought-provoking to this day. By choosing the classics, you not only ensure that you’re getting a high-quality read, but you’re also connecting with the rich literary tradition that has shaped our understanding of the world.
Another tip I have for selecting books is to follow your curiosity. If a topic or author piques your interest, don’t hesitate to explore it further. Trust your instincts and allow your reading choices to be guided by what excites and intrigues you. You never know what new insights and perspectives you might discover along the way.
Ultimately, the joy of reading lies in the journey of discovery, in the exploration of new worlds and ideas. So, whether you prefer the tactile experience of a physical book or the convenience of a Kindle, the most important thing is to keep reading, keep exploring, and keep expanding your mind. And who knows, maybe one day you’ll be the one recommending books to others, guiding them on their own literary adventures. When it comes to choosing a book on a particular subject, especially a complex and multi-faceted one like the life of a historical figure, it can be overwhelming to decide which book to read. With so many options available, it’s easy to get caught up in the latest trends or the most up-to-date research. However, as a reader, the focus should be on finding the best-written book, rather than the most current or academically respected one.
One approach to finding the best-written book on a subject is to seek recommendations from trusted sources. This could involve asking ChatGPT for suggestions, consulting with friends who share similar interests, or simply doing a quick Google search to see what book is considered the best-written on a particular topic. By prioritizing well-written books over the most recent publications, readers can ensure a more enjoyable and enriching reading experience.
It’s important to remember that recency bias can often lead readers astray, causing them to overlook older but still highly relevant and well-written books. While staying informed about the latest research and scholarship is important, it’s equally crucial to seek out books that are engaging, well-crafted, and thoughtfully written.
One strategy for gaining a deeper understanding of a subject is to read multiple books on the same topic. By reading two different books that offer contrasting perspectives or approaches, readers can gain a more comprehensive and nuanced understanding of the subject matter. This approach allows readers to connect different pieces of information, compare and contrast differing viewpoints, and ultimately develop a more well-rounded grasp of the topic.
When selecting books on a broad and complex subject like the history of a particular time period or figure, it can be more beneficial to choose books that focus on specific aspects or individual stories rather than attempting to cover the entire subject in a single volume. By delving into the details of individual stories or events, readers can gain a deeper appreciation for the larger context and themes of the subject matter. Additionally, books that focus on specific stories or individuals are often more engaging and memorable than comprehensive overviews.
In conclusion, when seeking out books on a particular subject, it’s important to prioritize well-written books over the most recent or academically respected ones. By seeking recommendations, reading multiple books on the same topic, and focusing on specific stories or aspects of a subject, readers can enhance their understanding and enjoyment of the material. Ultimately, the goal should be to find books that are engaging, thought-provoking, and well-crafted, rather than simply the most up-to-date or comprehensive ones. The conversation between Russ Roberts and James Marriott delves into the importance of books as a source of rich and contextual information that often goes unnoticed in today’s world of social media and quick bites of information. The example of Robert Caro’s biography of Lyndon Johnson is used to illustrate how a seemingly mundane subject can actually provide a deep understanding of history, politics, and human nature.
Roberts and Marriott emphasize the value of books in providing a narrative that allows readers to enter the mind of the author and experience a story in a way that tweets or blog posts simply cannot replicate. The richness of information in a well-written book is highlighted as a key factor in the power of books to connect ideas, emotions, and experiences in a way that is unique and absorbing.
The discussion also touches on the idea that a great book is not just a collection of facts and events, but a carefully crafted narrative that weaves together themes, characters, and emotions to provide a deeper understanding of a subject. Whether it’s a biography, a history book, or a work of fiction, the best books are those that tell a compelling story that resonates with readers on a personal level.
In a world where information is constantly bombarding us from all sides, the conversation between Roberts and Marriott serves as a reminder of the enduring value of books as a source of knowledge, insight, and connection. Books offer a depth of understanding that is unmatched by any other form of media, and the experience of reading a great book is one that can enrich and enlighten us in ways that we may not even realize. about the power of the English language, or read a snippet of his speeches, and you’re just bowled over by his charisma and his ability to inspire. And, I think that complexity is what makes him such a fascinating figure to study.
Reading multiple biographies of a historical figure like Churchill allows us to see them in a more nuanced light. We can understand their flaws and shortcomings, as well as their strengths and accomplishments. It humanizes them and makes them more relatable, rather than just a distant figure from the past.
I think this ties into the broader point about the value of reading and learning in general. It’s not just about acquiring information or being able to recite facts and figures. It’s about deepening our understanding of the world and the people in it. It’s about developing empathy and perspective, and being able to see things from different angles.
So, I completely agree with the idea that simply listing facts and dates is not the most important thing when it comes to studying history. It’s about delving into the stories, the narratives, and the complexities of the past. It’s about gaining a deeper understanding of the human experience and how it has shaped the world we live in today. And, that is something that can only be achieved through a more imaginative and holistic approach to learning and scholarship. I have to admit, I am also guilty of being a book hoarder. I love my books and the stories they hold, and the idea of parting with them can be quite difficult. But, like you, I have found myself in situations where I have reluctantly lent out a book, only to never see it again.
It’s a bittersweet feeling, knowing that someone else is enjoying a book that was once in your possession. On one hand, it’s great to share the joy of reading with others and to spread the love of literature. But on the other hand, there’s a sense of loss and longing for that missing book on your shelf.
I can understand the British politeness that may compel you to say yes when someone asks to borrow a book. It’s hard to turn down a request, especially when it comes to something as personal as your own collection of books. And, like you, I also find myself feeling a bit of regret afterwards, knowing that I may never see that book again.
But, as you mentioned, there’s something special about sharing your books with others. It’s a way to connect over a shared love of literature and to pass on the stories that have meant so much to you. And, if that means sacrificing a book or two along the way, then perhaps it’s a small price to pay for the joy of spreading the magic of reading.
So, while I may still cringe a little inside when I lend out a book, I also recognize the value in sharing the gift of reading with others. And, who knows, maybe one day those borrowed books will find their way back to me, full of new stories and memories to share. In the meantime, I’ll continue to cherish my books and the adventures they hold, both on my shelf and out in the world. I have to agree with Russ Roberts on the idea of giving away books. It’s a habit that many of us book lovers have, and it’s a wonderful way to share the joy of reading with others. But, as he mentioned, there’s also the issue of books going missing or not being returned. It’s a common dilemma that many of us face when lending out our beloved books.
I can relate to James Marriott’s struggle of not being able to remember which book he has given away the most. It’s a testament to his generosity and love for sharing his favorite reads with others. As for me, the book that I have given away the most is probably “To Kill a Mockingbird” by Harper Lee. It’s a classic that I believe everyone should read at least once in their lifetime.
On the topic of marking and annotating books, I used to be like Russ Roberts, viewing it as a sacrilege to write in a book. But as I’ve grown older, I’ve come to see the value in making notes and underlining passages. It helps me engage more deeply with the text and allows me to revisit my thoughts and insights later on. I may not always go back and review my annotations, but the act of marking up a book has become a meaningful part of my reading experience.
I found James Marriott’s idea of underlining one sentence per page to be a helpful tip for focusing one’s concentration on a book. It’s a practice that I may try to incorporate into my reading routine, especially with challenging or complex texts. Slowing down and paying more attention to the words on the page can lead to a richer and more rewarding reading experience.
As for the book “Seiobo There Below” by László Krasznahorkai, I haven’t read it yet, but Russ Roberts’ description of his initial reaction to the book and how it ultimately became one of the most extraordinary reading experiences resonates with me. It’s a reminder that sometimes we have to push past our initial judgments and give a book a chance to reveal its true beauty and depth.
In conclusion, the act of giving away books, marking them up, and being open to new reading experiences all contribute to the richness and joy of being a book lover. Whether it’s sharing a favorite book with a friend or discovering a hidden gem in a novel that challenges our preconceptions, books have the power to connect us, inspire us, and enrich our lives in countless ways. ‘ I got in so much trouble. But, that book changed my life because it made me realize the power and beauty of reading, of storytelling, of the written word. It made me want to become a writer, to create stories and share them with others.
Another book that had a big impact on me was Sapiens by Yuval Noah Harari. It really opened my eyes to the history of humanity and how we have evolved over time. It made me think about the bigger picture, about our place in the world and our impact on it. It made me more aware of the interconnectedness of all things and the importance of taking care of our planet and each other.
Overall, books have always been a huge part of my life, shaping my thoughts and beliefs, inspiring me to learn and grow. And, while not every book I recommend may be a hit with everyone, I will continue to share my love of reading and the power of storytelling with others, in the hopes of sparking something magical in them as well. But, I find that even in those books that are marketed as life-changing, there are often nuggets of wisdom or interesting insights that can be valuable. So, even if a book is not your first choice or doesn’t immediately grab your attention, there may still be something worthwhile to take away from it.
I think the key is to approach reading with an open mind and a willingness to engage with the material, even if it’s not your preferred topic. And, as Johnson suggests, reading with inclination can make a much stronger impression and lead to a deeper understanding of the subject matter.
At the same time, I agree with the idea that reading should also be a pleasure. It’s important to strike a balance between reading what you’re interested in and challenging yourself with new ideas and perspectives. And, as James Marriott mentioned, the richness of books means that even a seemingly unrelated book can offer unexpected insights and knowledge.
Ultimately, the goal of reading should be to expand our minds, broaden our horizons, and deepen our understanding of the world around us. Whether it’s a book that changes the way we think, challenges our beliefs, or simply entertains us, every book we read has the potential to shape our lives in some way. And, as Dr. Johnson wisely said, reading with inclination can lead to a more fulfilling and enriching experience. In a recent conversation between two literary enthusiasts, a critique of modern nonfiction books was brought to light. The discussion centered around the trend of authors using studies from the social sciences to support their arguments, often presenting them as undeniable truths. The problem arises when these studies are not reliable or accurate, leading readers to form misconceptions based on false information.
One of the speakers expressed frustration with this modern phenomenon, noting that it is a departure from the kind of books they prefer to read. They believe that this trend of taking questionable studies and weaving them into a narrative to change readers’ lives is misleading and ultimately harmful. They emphasized the importance of critically evaluating the sources and information presented in nonfiction books to avoid falling into the trap of misinformation.
The conversation then turned to the topic of abridged versions of classic works, with one speaker recommending a good abridged version of Boswell’s Life of Johnson as a way to ease into the lengthy book. While they typically have a moral aversion to abridgments, they acknowledged that in certain cases, such as books of anecdotes like Boswell’s, an abridged version can serve as a helpful entry point for readers.
The discussion also touched on the idea of a “sweet spot” in popular nonfiction books, spanning from around 1960 to 2006. The speakers suggested that books written within this time frame strike a balance between accessibility and professionalism, making them more engaging and informative for readers. They contrasted this with books written before 1960 and after 2006, which they believe may suffer from being either too old-fashioned or too influenced by modern distractions and academic jargon.
Overall, the conversation highlighted the importance of discerning readership when it comes to nonfiction books, urging readers to be critical of the information presented and to seek out well-researched, engaging works that stand the test of time. By being mindful of the sources and narratives in nonfiction books, readers can avoid falling prey to false ideas and instead gain a deeper understanding of the world around them. Russ Roberts: Interesting. I love Stefan Zweig. His writing is so elegant and insightful. His ability to delve into the human psyche and emotions is truly remarkable. I highly recommend his works if you haven’t given him a chance yet.
James Marriott: I’ll have to revisit Stefan Zweig then. Maybe I just haven’t found the right book of his to capture my interest. It’s always worth giving authors a second chance.
Russ Roberts: Absolutely. Sometimes it just takes finding the right book to truly appreciate an author’s talent. And that’s the beauty of literature – there are always new discoveries to be made and new authors to explore.
James Marriott: Definitely. That’s the joy of reading – the endless possibilities of finding new voices and perspectives that can enrich our lives. It’s important to keep an open mind and be willing to step outside of our comfort zones to discover hidden gems in the world of literature.
Russ Roberts: Well said. Thank you for sharing your insights on Peter Brown and Claire Tomalin. I look forward to exploring their works and expanding my literary horizons.
James Marriott: My pleasure. I hope you enjoy their books as much as I have. Happy reading! Russ Roberts and James Marriott’s discussion on the works of Stefan Zweig and John Carey’s quote on great works of literature provide valuable insights into the power of fiction in conveying emotional truths. Zweig’s memoir, “The World of Yesterday,” is praised for its extraordinary insights into the rise of the Nazis and the author’s own remarkable life. Despite Zweig’s popularity in the past, his fiction is met with mixed reviews, with Russ Roberts expressing admiration for some of his short stories but not all.
John Carey’s quote emphasizes the importance of fiction in evoking emotional understanding rather than simply conveying factual information. Fiction, as Carey argues, allows readers to feel what it would be like to know the truth, providing a deeper and more immersive experience than nonfiction. James Marriott expands on this idea by discussing his emotional connection to Elena Ferrante’s novels, which offered him a profound understanding of the experiences of teenage girls in Naples.
The conversation also touches on the underrated nature of emotional understanding in literature, with Marriott highlighting the value of experiencing truths through fiction. He suggests that this emotional connection can provide insights that go beyond mere facts, allowing readers to empathize and connect with characters and situations on a deeper level.
Furthermore, the discussion turns to the works of Anthony Trollope, another underrated author whose novels offer intricate portraits of ambition, corruption, and ethical dilemmas. Russ Roberts praises Trollope’s ability to depict these complex themes in a way that resonates with readers, suggesting that fiction has a unique power to embed these truths in the reader’s consciousness.
In conclusion, the conversation between Russ Roberts and James Marriott underscores the importance of emotional understanding in literature and the unique ability of fiction to convey profound truths. Through the works of authors like Stefan Zweig and Anthony Trollope, readers are encouraged to explore the depths of human experience and engage with complex themes in a way that goes beyond mere facts. Ultimately, fiction serves as a powerful tool for connecting with the emotional truths that shape our understanding of the world. But, it’s also about grappling with language, with meaning, with the way words can be arranged to create something entirely new and unique. Poetry challenges us to see the world in a different light, to question our assumptions, and to explore the depths of our own emotions and experiences.
When we read poetry, we are forced to slow down, to savor each word, each line, each stanza. We are asked to engage with the text on a deeper level, to think about what the poet is trying to convey, and to consider how it resonates with our own lives.
And, just like with great novels, poetry can change the way we see ourselves and the world around us. It can open our eyes to new perspectives, to different ways of thinking, and to the beauty and complexity of language itself.
In a world that is increasingly focused on instant gratification, on quick fixes and easy answers, poetry reminds us of the value of patience, of contemplation, of struggle. It challenges us to push beyond our comfort zones, to embrace ambiguity and uncertainty, and to seek out the deeper truths that lie beneath the surface of our everyday lives.
So, the next time you pick up a book of poetry, don’t be afraid to grapple with it, to wrestle with its complexities and its challenges. Allow yourself to be drawn into the world of the poet, to explore the depths of language and meaning, and to discover the profound beauty and power of poetry. Who knows what new insights and revelations you might uncover along the way? Poetry is often seen as a means of expressing emotions and feelings, but it is much more than that. Great poetry has the power to communicate something that cannot be easily described, something ineffable. It is a way to access a deeper layer of reality, a realm beyond the superficial material world.
James Marriott and Russ Roberts discuss the importance of poetry in their conversation, highlighting how poetry can help us see things that cannot be easily put into words. While it may sound absurd to claim that poetry can show us a deeper reality, many poets throughout history have attempted to do just that.
Marriott recommends the works of poets such as Philip Larkin, Alfred, Lord Tennyson, and Sylvia Plath. Larkin’s poems are easily accessible and lovable, while Tennyson’s beautiful language is a joy to read. Plath, often dismissed as over-emotional, is compared to expressionism in the visual arts for her ability to push language to its extremes.
In a world where poetry is often seen as out of fashion, it is important to remember the profound impact that it can have on our lives. Poetry has the power to console us, to restore us to a wider plane of significance where everything else seems petty. It is a deeply personal and meaningful form of self-expression that can touch us in ways that nothing else can.
So, the next time you come across a poem that doesn’t seem to make sense at first, take a moment to consider what the poet is trying to communicate. There may be a deeper meaning hidden within the words, waiting to be discovered. Poetry is a powerful tool for accessing the ineffable, for seeing beyond the surface and into the heart of reality.
