How to Save Big With Smart DIY Holiday Gifts

High prices have Americans looking for creative ways to save on holiday gifts this season. According to Deloitte’s 2025 Holiday Retail Survey, roughly half of respondents said they plan to give DIY gifts this season to save money. Nearly 4 in 10 survey respondents are considering handmade presents, and 3 in 10 plan to make homemade food gifts.

On its face, this seems like a great way to save a few bucks while getting into the holiday spirit. There’s no shortage of Pinterest boards and YouTube tutorials to search for inspiration. Even a quick Google search turns up a blizzard of advice for DIY sugar scrubs, bath bombs, baskets, coasters, candles, knits, wreaths — the list is seemingly endless, and that’s before you even get to a feast’s worth of cooked, baked, and canned goodies.

But experts in cooking and crafting caution that it still takes strategic planning to make sure that your homespun holiday gifts don’t unravel your budget. “People could possibly save money by making their own gifts, but it could get really expensive too,” says Sara Croymans, an extension educator in the department of family, health, and well-being at the University of Minnesota Extension. “We really encourage folks to plan ahead so they know what they’re going to do.”

What sets a successful DIY gift-giver apart? Preparation is key, Croymans says. “They have a list, they have a budget, and they start early.” Whether you’re stitching, stirring, or stamping, experts say there are a handful of pricey pitfalls that can derail your festively frugal plans. Here’s what the pros say you should avoid — and what you should do instead.

Shopping at craft stores for supplies

“I rarely shop at the specialty stores because they are overpriced, in my opinion,” Marlene Alexander, founder of the Dollar Store Style blog, says via email. Instead, experts recommend hitting up dollar stores, warehouse clubs, and big-box retailers. Another expert tip: You can often get better deals on supplies and ingredients, especially when buying in bulk, if you buy from the same places where the pros shop. “If you look at restaurant supply stores, you can sometimes save a lot of money that way,” says Luci Mosesso, a 4-H agent at West Virginia University Extension.

All of the experts Money consulted also urged DIY gift-givers to hit up local thrift stores for supplies and containers. “Thrift stores are a great place to go to find DIY types of supplies,” Croymans says. “You can find lots of crafty items…

Creating handmade gifts for your loved ones is not only a thoughtful gesture but can also be a sustainable and eco-friendly way to spread holiday cheer. However, there are some common pitfalls to avoid in order to keep your budget in check and minimize your impact on the environment. Here are some tips to help you stay on track with your crafting endeavors:

Avoid buying pricey kits

While crafting kits may seem convenient, they can often be more expensive than sourcing the individual materials yourself. Consider buying supplies separately, especially if you already have some items on hand. This not only saves money but also allows you to customize your gifts to suit the recipient’s preferences.

Use what you have

Before heading to the store, take inventory of what you already own. Repurpose fabric scraps, forage for natural materials, and get creative with items you have lying around the house. Not only does this save money, but it also reduces waste and promotes a more sustainable approach to crafting.

Skip the fancy packaging

When it comes to presentation, simplicity is key. Avoid expensive containers and opt for budget-friendly options like Ziploc bags or colored Saran wrap. Remember, it’s the thought that counts, not the packaging. Focus on creating meaningful gifts rather than splurging on elaborate wrapping materials.

Master the process

Before diving into a new crafting or cooking project, take the time to educate yourself on the process. Watch tutorials, read multiple recipes, and give yourself plenty of time to practice and perfect your skills. By mastering the techniques involved, you can avoid costly mistakes and ensure that your gifts turn out beautifully.

Don’t splurge on equipment

If your holiday plans involve baking or crafting, resist the urge to buy expensive equipment that you may only use once. Stick to simple recipes and projects that require minimal tools, and make use of what you already have in your kitchen or craft room. This not only saves money but also prevents unnecessary waste.

By following these tips, you can create beautiful handmade gifts that are both budget-friendly and environmentally conscious. Whether you’re sewing, baking, or crafting, remember that the thought and effort you put into your gifts are what truly matter. With a little creativity and resourcefulness, you can spread holiday joy without breaking the bank or harming the planet.