Four paths Toronto’s front office can explore this offseason involving Mitch Marner, former captain

The Toronto Maple Leafs are facing a pivotal offseason as they navigate the uncertain futures of Mitch Marner and former captain John Tavares. Both players are set to become free agents on July 1, leaving the team with some tough decisions to make. As the organization enters a new era, let’s explore four potential paths that the Maple Leafs’ front office can take regarding its Core 4.

### Re-sign both Marner and Tavares

The most challenging option would be to re-sign both Mitch Marner and John Tavares. With a combined cap hit of over $21 million last season, the Leafs would need to negotiate new deals that fit within their projected $25.7 million cap space. While Tavares may have to take a pay cut, Marner is likely seeking a substantial raise. This scenario seems unlikely given the financial constraints.

### Let both Marner and Tavares walk

Another difficult choice would be to let both Marner and Tavares leave in free agency. This would open up two key spots in the team’s lineup, requiring the Leafs to find replacements for their top six forwards. With ample cap space available, the team could explore the free-agent market for solutions, although it may be challenging to find suitable replacements.

### Keep Marner, let Tavares walk

One option could be to prioritize re-signing Mitch Marner while allowing John Tavares to depart. This strategy would involve investing heavily in Marner while using the savings from Tavares’ departure to address other roster needs. It would require the Leafs to find a suitable replacement for Tavares but could provide flexibility in building a balanced team.

### Keep Tavares, let Marner walk

The most probable scenario at this point seems to be retaining John Tavares while allowing Mitch Marner to explore free agency. Reports suggest that Tavares is keen on staying with the Leafs, while Marner is considering offers from multiple teams. By retaining Tavares and parting ways with Marner, the Leafs could save on Marner’s potential high salary and allocate resources to other areas of need.

In conclusion, the Toronto Maple Leafs are facing a critical offseason as they navigate the futures of Mitch Marner and John Tavares. While the ideal scenario would be to retain both players, the salary cap constraints may necessitate some tough decisions. The front office will need to carefully weigh their options to ensure the team remains competitive in the upcoming season.