Vatican’s ‘trial of the century’ resumes after prosecutors suffer setbacks on appeal

The Vatican City’s high-profile “trial of the century” has entered its appeals phase, with significant developments that could impact the outcome of the case. The trial involves Cardinal Angelo Becciu and eight other defendants who were convicted of financial crimes in 2023 after a lengthy trial. However, recent setbacks have raised questions about the credibility of the prosecution and the fairness of the proceedings.

The Vatican’s Court of Cassation upheld a lower court’s decision to dismiss the prosecutors’ appeal, limiting the possibility of overturning the verdicts and sentences for the defendants. Additionally, the Vatican’s chief prosecutor, Alessandro Diddi, resigned from the case following revelations of questionable conduct related to WhatsApp chats that cast doubt on the integrity of the trial.

The WhatsApp chats revealed a behind-the-scenes effort to target Becciu, implicating Vatican police, prosecutors, and even Pope Francis. Defense attorneys argued that Diddi’s impartiality was compromised, leading to his resignation from the case. Despite these issues, the appeals court affirmed the validity of Diddi’s prosecutorial activities, allowing the case to proceed.

The original trial focused on the Vatican’s investment of 350 million euros in a London property, with allegations of embezzlement and extortion involving Becciu and other defendants. The trial resulted in convictions for some defendants but acquitted them on many counts. Both the defendants and prosecutors appealed the verdicts, leading to the current appeals phase.

The defense is now focusing on challenging Francis’ role in the investigation, particularly regarding executive decrees granting prosecutors extensive powers, including wiretapping, without proper oversight or transparency. Legal experts have criticized the secrecy and ad hoc nature of these decrees, raising concerns about the defendants’ right to a fair trial.

Despite these challenges, the Vatican maintains that the defendants received a fair trial. The appeals process continues, with the defense pursuing arguments related to the legality of the investigation and the role of Pope Francis in the case. The outcome of the appeals phase will determine the final resolution of this high-profile and controversial trial.

Associated Press religion coverage is supported by a collaboration with The Conversation US, funded by Lilly Endowment Inc. The AP is responsible for the content of this article.