Where jobs are scarce, over 1 million people could dodge Trump’s Medicaid work rules

As the deadline for President Trump’s new domestic policy law approaches in January 2027, millions of Medicaid enrollees may have a way out of the impending work requirement if they live in counties with high unemployment rates. The law mandates that adult, nondisabled Medicaid enrollees in 42 states and Washington, D.C., must work, volunteer, or attend school for 80 hours a month to maintain their health coverage.

However, under the law, Medicaid enrollees in counties with an unemployment rate of at least 8% or 1.5 times the national average could be exempt from the work requirement if their state applies for an exemption. A recent analysis by KFF indicates that this exemption could provide relief to potentially millions of Americans facing the challenge of finding employment to secure health insurance.

The Congressional Budget Office projects that the work requirement could impact 18.5 million Medicaid enrollees, leading to about 5.3 million individuals losing their coverage by 2034. Analysts factored the unemployment rate exemption into these projections. Only states that expanded Medicaid under the Affordable Care Act or a special waiver are required to implement the work requirement.

Exemption Criteria

The number of individuals eligible for exemption depends on how the Trump administration interprets the law and whether states apply for exemptions. If individuals in counties with unemployment rates above the specified thresholds for any month over a 12-month period are exempted, around 4.6 million Medicaid enrollees in 386 counties could qualify for exemption based on the latest data, according to KFF.

However, a stricter threshold based on the average unemployment rate over a 12-month period is more likely to be adopted by the Trump administration. Under this standard, approximately 1.4 million Medicaid enrollees in 158 counties could be exempted, accounting for about 7% of those subject to work requirements in expansion states.

Implementation Challenges

States would need to apply for exemptions on behalf of individuals in eligible counties, and the duration of the exemptions would be determined by the federal government. Health advocates are concerned that some Republican-led states may refrain from applying for exemptions to limit enrollment, as seen with SNAP exemptions.

While the unemployment rate exemption offers a potential lifeline for many Medicaid enrollees, challenges in navigating the work requirement system and potential coverage losses remain. Critics argue that the reporting requirements add unnecessary bureaucratic hurdles for individuals already working or eligible for exemptions.

Despite the potential impact of the exemption, concerns about the overall impact of the work requirement persist. Jennifer Wagner from the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities acknowledges the value of exemptions in areas with limited job opportunities but emphasizes the need for state cooperation to ensure effective implementation.

Conclusion

As the Medicaid work requirement deadline approaches, the high unemployment rate exemption offers a glimmer of hope for many enrollees facing challenges in meeting the new mandate. While the exemption could provide relief for millions, the ultimate success of the program hinges on state participation and effective implementation.

KFF Health News is dedicated to providing comprehensive coverage of health issues, serving as a vital resource for health policy research, polling, and journalism.