Perps with HUNDREDS of arrests make a mockery of New York’s criminal-justice system
New York City is facing a major issue with shoplifters and petty criminals taking advantage of the criminal-justice system, with Anthony White being a prime example. White, a 63-year-old serial shoplifter, has an astonishing 254 arrests to his name. Despite being caught again in May on burglary charges for stealing from stores he had been banned from, he was released once more.
In one instance, White was accused of stealing two shirts from a shop at Rockefeller Center, with prosecutors requesting $3,000 cash or a $60,000 bond. However, Judge Kacie Lally released him on supervised release. This leniency is not an isolated case, as other repeat offenders like Davaugh Gethers and Laron Mark have also been arrested numerous times.
Jacob “Jessica” Poole, with 103 shoplifting arrests, stole $215 worth of chicken from a market in the South Street Seaport in April. Despite prosecutors requesting bail in recent arrests, judges continue to set these offenders free. The leniency towards repeat offenders can be attributed to policies like Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg’s “Day 1” memo, which discourages prosecution of low-level offenses and avoids incarceration.
The combination of soft judges, pro-criminal prosecutors, bail reform, and anti-cop laws has created a system where repeat offenders can continue their criminal activities with little consequence. Law enforcement officers are aware that arresting shoplifters may not lead to meaningful consequences due to these reforms.
This leniency has led to a situation where store owners are hesitant to report crimes, resulting in items like toothpaste being locked up. Tragic incidents, like the one involving CVS worker Scotty Enoe and homeless serial shoplifter Charles Brito, highlight the dangers of allowing shoplifters to go unchecked.
Ultimately, the failure to hold repeat offenders accountable benefits no one, not even the criminals themselves. New York’s progressive policies have created a system where individuals can rack up hundreds of arrests without facing significant penalties. It is clear that a shift in approach is needed to address the issue of rampant shoplifting and petty crime in the city.



