Americans say tipping practices ‘have become ridiculous’ as digital prompts push higher gratuities

1 1 minute read

Americans are expressing frustration with the increasing prevalence of digital tipping screens in restaurants. According to a recent Popmenu survey, 78% of consumers believe tipping practices have become excessive, with 74% noticing restaurants raising suggested gratuity amounts on payment screens.

The survey of 1,000 adults in March also revealed that 59% feel pressured to leave a tip when faced with these prompts. However, restaurant owners like Vicki Parmelee from Jumby Bay Island Grill in Jupiter, Florida, believe that traditional tipping is still widely supported by diners.

While customers appreciate the opportunity to reward good service, they are growing increasingly uncomfortable with being prompted to tip in situations where gratuities were once optional. For example, Parmelee mentioned the annoyance of being expected to tip for a simple coffee order at a service counter.

Derek Simms, CEO of Simms Hospitality Group in Texas, acknowledged the awkwardness even within the restaurant industry when dealing with modern tipping screens.

Americans are fed up with ‘tip creep’ and digital tipping screens, a new survey reveals.

Despite the digital pressure, 36% of consumers prefer to enter a custom tip amount rather than selecting preset options on screens. Both Parmelee and Simms emphasized the importance of earning tips rather than expecting them, to maintain customer satisfaction and loyalty.

Restaurant bill in a tray with cash, coins, and a pen. — Despite digital pressure, 59% feel compelled to tip, but many now customize amounts, bypassing preset options on screens.

While consumers are becoming more comfortable skipping gratuities in certain situations, they still value rewarding exceptional service at full-service restaurants. Parmelee highlighted the importance of recognizing outstanding service by tipping above the standard 20% in those cases.