Trump administration can’t block SNAP recipients in 5 states from buying soda and candy, judge rules

The Trump administration’s efforts to allow states to bar SNAP recipients from using their benefits to purchase soft drinks and candy have been blocked by a federal judge. The Agriculture Department’s approval of the restrictions was deemed to exceed its authority, as Congress had defined what foods are eligible under the SNAP program.

The ruling, issued by Judge Amy Berman Jackson, sided with SNAP recipients in five states who had sued the agency, arguing that the ban would destabilize food access for those relying on food stamps. The plaintiffs also pointed out that the restrictions could make it difficult for individuals with chronic illnesses to access necessary foods and beverages.

While the ruling only applies to the five states involved in the lawsuit, it could have implications for the 18 other states approved for similar bans. Thirteen of these states have yet to implement their SNAP restriction rules, according to the Food Research & Action Center (FRAC).

The setback for the “Make America Healthy Again” campaign, supported by Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins, emphasizes the importance of ensuring taxpayer funds are not used to purchase unhealthy foods. The Agriculture Department has permitted 23 states to implement restrictions through waivers, with the goal of combatting obesity, diabetes, and chronic diseases.

However, the ruling reaffirms that the USDA cannot bypass the legal parameters governing SNAP and redefine what constitutes eligible food items. The complexity of the eligibility restrictions has led to confusion among retailers and SNAP recipients, with some states implementing counterintuitive rules.

Moving forward, the decision may provide a roadmap for future challenges to similar SNAP restrictions. The ruling highlights the need for clarity and consistency in SNAP regulations to ensure that the program effectively serves low-income Americans in need of assistance with purchasing groceries.

The Associated Press contributed to this report.