What Not to Discount This Black Friday
This morning, while I’m on sabbatical, one thought keeps showing up: a discount can bring in cash today and quietly send the wrong message about what your business is worth.
Black Friday is built to make everything feel urgent. The clock is ticking. Competitors are cutting prices. Somebody’s dashboard is flashing red or green, depending on the hour. And in that noise, it’s easy to reach for the fastest lever you can pull: take a little more off.
But a lower price isn’t always a better offer. Sometimes it’s just a cheaper way to weaken something you spent years building.
So before the rush arrives, let’s talk about what I would keep off the sale table.
Don’t discount the thing that makes you you
Every business has a product, service, or promise that carries the brand’s name even when the logo isn’t on it. It’s the thing customers think of first. The one that earns trust. The one that says, “This is what we do, and we do it well.”
That’s your core.
If you slash the price on that offer every time the calendar says “sale,” customers may start to wonder whether the regular price was ever real. They may also learn to wait. Not because they don’t like your product, but because you’ve taught them that the best move is to hold off until the next markdown.
That’s a costly lesson to teach.
Research on promotions has found that frequent discounts can affect customers’ reference prices, the prices they come to expect, and may weaken brand equity over time. One study examining promotions and brand equity found the negative effect was especially notable for premium brands and brands with strong existing equity.
The practical point isn’t “never discount.” It’s this: don’t casually discount the offer that explains your value. If your core product needs a permanent markdown to move, ask whether the problem is really price, or whether it’s positioning, reach, experience, or clarity.
Don’t discount your standards to make a deadline
A deadline can be useful. It can focus a team and help customers make a decision. But urgency is not a permission slip to make promises you can’t keep.
Don’t promise delivery dates your operation can’t support. Don’t stretch inventory beyond what you can fulfill. Don’t turn a customer-service team into a pressure valve for an offer that was designed without asking what happens after checkout.
A sale is not a win if the back end becomes a mess.
And when you advertise a discount, make sure the discount is honest. The FTC’s guidance on former-price comparisons says that a former price should be a genuine price at which the product was openly and actively offered for a reasonably substantial period. In plain language: don’t invent a high “was” price just to make the “now” price look irresistible.
Your standards are not a seasonal expense. Keep them intact when the pressure peaks.
Don’t discount relationships into transactions
Your best customers are not just a list of email addresses waiting for a code. They’re people who trusted you before the countdown timer appeared.
That trust deserves more imagination than another generic “20% off” message.
Instead of asking, “How much can we take off?” ask, “What would make this feel worthwhile to the people who already believe in us?” Maybe it’s early access. A useful bundle. A loyalty benefit. A service upgrade. A thoughtful thank-you. A way to get something they genuinely need without turning the relationship into a race to the cheapest price.
A discount can be part of customer appreciation. It shouldn’t be the only language your business knows how to speak.
And if your offer is only attractive when it’s marked down, don’t assume you have a loyalty problem. You may have a value story that needs work.
Don’t discount your long-term brand for a short-term spike
Black Friday numbers can be intoxicating. A big sales day feels like proof that everything is working. But revenue is one part of the picture, not the whole picture.
What did it cost to generate those sales? Did the promotion attract the right buyers? Did it bring future demand forward, or create new demand? Will those customers return at full price? Did the team deliver the experience your brand is known for?
I want leaders to look beyond the checkout total. Consider margin, returns, repeat purchases, customer feedback, and whether people still see the value in your regular offer when the sale ends.
The danger isn’t simply making less money on one item. It’s resetting expectations across your whole business. If customers start to think the sale price is the “real” price, then every full-price sale becomes a harder conversation.
A strong brand has more than one way to create value. It can offer convenience, expertise, service, quality, access, or peace of mind. A price cut may attract attention. But your brand is what gives people a reason to stay after the banner comes down.
Draw the line before the countdown begins
Here’s the practical move I’d make today: write down what will never go on sale.
Keep it simple. Name the products, standards, promises, and relationships you refuse to trade for a temporary bump in sales. Then decide what can be part of a promotion: older inventory, a seasonal offer, a carefully designed bundle, or an added benefit that fits your brand.
A line written before the pressure hits is easier to hold than one you’re trying to draw in the middle of a team meeting while everyone’s watching the numbers.
And if the answer is “we’re not discounting this,” be ready to say what you’re offering instead. Hold a product at full price because the price reflects its value. Reward loyal customers with access. Explain the craftsmanship, service, or result behind the offer. Give people a clear reason to choose you without asking them to wait for a markdown.
A boundary is only useful if you can keep it when keeping it gets uncomfortable.
Black Friday will ask what you’re willing to cut. Your job is to know what you’re not willing to compromise.
So, before the inbox fills and the countdown starts: What will you refuse to discount this season, and what does that boundary protect?
For more morning leadership reflections, visit ByrdOlogy in the Morning.
J. Richard Byrd \ www.jrichardbyrd.com \ is a business development mentor, media strategist, and CEO of The ByrdOlogy Group. ByrdOlogy In the Morning is a 4-minute daily leadership devotional available on YouTube, Spotify, and all major podcast platforms. \ www.BLKHustle.com/byrdologyinthemorning



